PedsDocTalk Podcast
A podcast for parents regarding the health and wellness of their children.
In this Follow-Up episode, Dr. Mona is joined by registered dietitian Jennifer Anderson of Kids Eat in Color to discuss navigating sugar, sweets and treats with your kids. They explore how using candy as a bribe, hyping up desserts and forbidding sweets can unintentionally place treats on a pedestal. Jennifer recommends approaching food without good-or-bad labels and to help kids learn moderation.
They discuss:
– How overhyping treats places them on an unhealthy emotional pedestal
– That rigid good-or-bad food labels confuse children about eating habits
– Bribing with candy reduces kids’ intrinsic motivation for vegetables
– How finishing plates for dessert disrupts children’s natural hunger cues
– That parents can promote balanced nutrition without creating food guilt
Get Jennifer Anderson’s new book, Feed Them Well (paid link)
Want more? Listen to the full, original episode.
Our podcasts are also now on YouTube. If you prefer a video podcast with closed captioning, check us out there and subscribe to PedsDocTalk.
Get trusted pediatric advice, relatable parenting insights, and evidence-based tips delivered straight to your inbox—join thousands of parents who rely on the PDT newsletter to stay informed, supported, and confident. Join the newsletter!
Shop Dr. Mona’s favorite products: https://shopmy.us/shop/pedsdoctalk (paid link)
And don’t forget to follow @pedsdoctalkpodcast on Instagram—our new space just for parents looking for real talk and real support.
We love the sponsors that make this show possible! You can always find all the special deals and codes for all our current sponsors on the PedsDocTalk Podcast Sponsorships page of the website.
00;00;00;02 – 00;00;03;14
Dr. Mona
Welcome back to the follow up.
00;00;03;16 – 00;00;23;19
Dr. Mona
It’s Doctor Mona, and this is a series on the PedsDocTalk podcast, where we revisit a past episode in less time than it takes your kid to beg for another piece of Halloween candy. I’m referring this episode because it’s between Halloween and the holidays, and that’s Sugar season baby. And I think this conversation is especially important right now.
00;00;23;22 – 00;00;41;01
Dr. Mona
And to be honest, my husband and I agree on a lot of things when it comes to parenting, but this is actually the one area where we have different opinions. He leans more towards the restricting of sweets, and he even suggested throwing away the Halloween candy. And let me tell you, I was just as upset as the kids.
00;00;41;03 – 00;01;09;25
Dr. Mona
But it sparked a really important conversation in our home about balance, because I understand wanting to create a balanced nutritional diet. I’m a pediatrician. I know that nutritional concerns of a lot of added sugar, but I also know that when we make certain foods forbidden, we can unintentionally make them even more desirable and our kids are going to encounter candy, cookies, cupcakes, and all sorts of yummy sweet goodies throughout their lives at school, birthday parties, holidays, and beyond.
00;01;09;26 – 00;01;40;23
Dr. Mona
So how do we teach moderation without creating fear, guilt, or obsession around sweets? That’s why I’m bringing back my conversation with Jennifer Anderson, registered dietitian founder of Kids Eat in Color and author of the new book Feed Them Well A Guide to Raising Healthy, Confident Eaters for life. It’s a fantastic resource for parents who want to help their kids eat a variety of foods, handle picky eating, and develop a healthy relationship with food and their bodies without turning every meal into a battle, including us sweets.
00;01;40;25 – 00;01;58;28
Dr. Mona
In this episode, we talk about how we unintentionally put sweets on a pedestal. What it actually means to raise kids with a healthy relationship with food, and why labeling foods as good or bad can backfire. Because I want my kids to enjoy a cupcake and understand that they can’t eat cupcakes all day. Just like we can’t eat broccoli all day.
00;01;59;00 – 00;02;25;06
Dr. Mona
I want them to learn moderation, but I also want them to enjoy food without guilt or shame. You can learn more about Jennifer at Kids Eat in color.com. Follow her on Instagram at kids Dot eatin Dot color and check out her new book, Feed Them Well wherever Books are sold. And remember, if you love this conversation, then please make sure you download the full episode wherever you get your podcasts, and make sure to share it on social and tag the PedsDocTalk podcast.
00;02;25;11 – 00;02;37;04
Dr. Mona
And kids dot eat eggs Sinclair when you do. Let’s get into this very sweet conversation.
00;02;37;07 – 00;02;55;28
Dr. Mona
I love cupcakes, I want my son to love cupcakes because they are delicious. And the thing is, though, obviously we’re trying to balance sweetened treats and all the things that are yummy in our life with obviously nutrition as well. You know, we can’t eat sweet treats all day every day, but how do we balance this? And we’re talking about putting sweets and treats on a pedestal.
00;02;55;28 – 00;03;04;18
Dr. Mona
So if you can describe to maybe someone who’s listening, what does that mean? And how do we do that either intentionally or unintentionally?
00;03;04;20 – 00;03;24;08
Jennifer Anderson
Sure. So let’s say you’ve never had an M&M before. And I come to you and I say, hey Doctor Mariah, would you like? And I’m Adam, and you’re like, okay, sure. And you eat it and you say, oh, wow, this is delicious. And they say, oh, great. Yeah. And maybe we talk about how delicious and maybe don’t, but then that’s over and then we talk about something else.
00;03;24;10 – 00;03;42;02
Jennifer Anderson
But then maybe I come to you and I say, oh my gosh, I had this amazing, incredible thing today. And because you’ve done such a great job with all of your work, I just really want to bring you this special thing. And here it is on a plate. Your mind is in the absolutely blown by this thing.
00;03;42;02 – 00;04;00;06
Jennifer Anderson
It’s M&M like, and I’m just hyping it up. I am hyping it up and and I can tie it into that. I can say, you know what you’ve had such a long week and you’ve been working so hard. Here are these M&Ms for you. And all of a sudden I have taken an enjoyable experience and turned it into something else totally different.
00;04;00;12 – 00;04;23;19
Jennifer Anderson
Now, you brought in your emotional state, and I brought in whether you deserve something, and I have just made a really big deal out of those seminars. And sometimes as parents, we unknowingly do that with eminems or treats are absolutely anything. Eminem was the first one that came to mind, but it can be absolutely anything. And what we’re doing is we’re bringing more attention to these things than they need to have.
00;04;23;24 – 00;04;44;02
Jennifer Anderson
Like, yeah, I love my potato chips. I mean, everybody knows the world knows that. I’m like potato chip person. Yeah, I love my salads and I love them with potato chips. So I love it. So, you know, I think sometimes we fall into this trap of thinking good art, either good or bad. There is this black and white thing there, good or bad.
00;04;44;05 – 00;05;09;06
Jennifer Anderson
And we’ve heard because of this wider diet culture around us, it’s a culture that’s obsessed with thinness and getting then same, then all this stuff. Because of that, we’ve decided that certain foods have a lot of calories or bad, certain foods that have a lot of calories are good. And so we we’ve developed this really, unfortunate perspective of food where it’s either good or bad, it’s gonna help us get better or not.
00;05;09;06 – 00;05;29;00
Jennifer Anderson
And that’s just trickled all the way down to how we interact with these foods with our children. And adding to that, we know that kids love them and they’re willing to do things for them. And then we’re like, oh, maybe I’ll use them as a reward to, oh, I can get them to eat their broccoli if I bribe them with a lollipop.
00;05;29;03 – 00;06;00;06
Jennifer Anderson
And what we don’t realize when we’re doing that, along with making it a big deal, is that we’re saying, hey, guess what? Broccoli is bad. Lollipops are good. Sitting in the car is bad. We all know that. And that’s true. But like and and lollipops are good. And so not only are we making a big deal out of it, but we’re also saying, hey, these things are better, while at the same time we and preschool teachers and everybody is saying, oh, by the way, lollipops are bad for you.
00;06;00;09 – 00;06;25;04
Jennifer Anderson
So we’re kind of giving these kids its like really complicated life perspective of lollipops and candy and treated like all this stuff because kids are hearing as young as 2 or 3 years old. These treats are bad, right? Like there is a classic, kind of preschool activity sheet out there. It’s like circle the healthy foods, circle the unhealthy foods, and the candy is unhealthy.
00;06;25;07 – 00;06;44;29
Jennifer Anderson
So we’re telling them that at the same time, we’re using the candy as bribes, telling the kids also that it’s good for you to make them like broccoli less. Yeah. And then we’re also saying, oh, hey, this is a really amazing thing. We’re making a really big deal out of it. So we basically it’s complicated. It’s complicated for us.
00;06;44;29 – 00;06;59;17
Jennifer Anderson
And then we’re also just kind of passing that on to the kids. And in the end, what happens is kids really want candy. They want candy maybe even more than they would have. And they’re less likely to want the broccoli or, you know, whatever those foods are.
00;06;59;19 – 00;07;18;20
Dr. Mona
But Jennifer, when I bribe my kid with a M&M, he eats his broccoli and he eats it with me, forcing it into his mouth. So it’s working. That’s what I always hear, right? Like I’m like, no, it’s it’s a short term. Like, I got it, I got it. This is the secret. The bribing is working. But I know you probably have something to say for that.
00;07;18;20 – 00;07;19;04
Dr. Mona
Yeah.
00;07;19;06 – 00;07;38;07
Jennifer Anderson
Well, here’s how I like to put it. I like to put it like, yes, this is a short term solution. And we can put a hard stop there. We can say, yes, this is a short term solution. The thing is, after that short term solution, we know that when you’re bribing a child to do something, it can decrease their intrinsic motivation.
00;07;38;07 – 00;07;58;09
Jennifer Anderson
What does that basically mean? Their own desire to do something. Right. So we say, well, yeah, if you’re bribing your child, you properly. Yes. This could be a short term solution, which if we kind of go down that path, let’s say you have a child who’s in a some sort of medical situation and you really need them to eat X, Y, or Z.
00;07;58;11 – 00;08;14;21
Jennifer Anderson
It’s really important for their health right now. You know what might be a good solution for you? Bribing your child with them and UPS. Now, does that come without risk? No, it’s got a lot of risk that it could possibly come with. But I think this is the kind of nuance that we need to begin to hold on to.
00;08;14;23 – 00;08;35;05
Jennifer Anderson
Yeah, that might be a short term solution, but also what could happen? Your child could stop liking broccoli altogether now in have way not they’re not going to eat at all, or they’re much less likely to eat all vegetables or or they’re just fine. There’s always that possibility, right? Because we’re working with risk just because we bribe a kid, does it mean x, y, z?
00;08;35;05 – 00;08;58;02
Jennifer Anderson
Well, we don’t know what’s going to happen for real that we might know. Well, yeah, your child could become really obsessed with candy, and they might enjoy candy, and they may hide in the closet and eat candy. And that might have kind of tipped the balance for them into being more interesting in candy than they would have been had they not had that bribery happen.
00;08;58;04 – 00;09;18;02
Jennifer Anderson
At the same time. Like I said, there might be those times where you’re like, you know what, I have to get my child to eat this medication. They must they must for their health, have this medication. In that case, yes. What you are weighing the risks and the rewards for one, the pros and the cons of what is going to happen to your child.
00;09;18;06 – 00;09;36;01
Jennifer Anderson
And as parents, I feel like that’s what’s tricky for us, is to acknowledge, yeah, there could be a risk. You know, I might just be giving them the M&M, to get them properly, and it’s not that important. And therefore I might have to deal with the risks later. And now I have a kid who really doesn’t like broccoli, and I created more work for myself.
00;09;36;04 – 00;09;57;14
Jennifer Anderson
Or there might be times like, yeah, I know there’s risks, but that’s okay. I will deal with those. And right now I need to do this thing. So I think it’s tricky and there is a lot of nuance here. And so I always like to think if a parent is bribing their kids with candy right now, it doesn’t mean you’re a bad parent, right?
00;09;57;17 – 00;10;13;18
Jennifer Anderson
It doesn’t mean you’re doing a bad job, but it is a good opportunity to say, okay, why am I doing it? And is there something else I could do differently that might actually get me to the goal that I want a little bit better than using candy as a bribe?
00;10;13;20 – 00;10;33;20
Dr. Mona
Yeah. And in terms of like, oh, I mean, this is this is something that’s been passed down from like generations to I mean, I remember as a child, and it’s something that I still have put that on the pedestal where it’s like, okay, if you finish this, I will go get ice cream. You know, like, I remember my aunt would come over and she’d be like, if you finish your food and it would.
00;10;33;23 – 00;10;55;01
Dr. Mona
And so you’re doing two things. You’re bribing them, but you’re also not allowing that child to listen to their hunger cues. Yeah. At the meal. Right. It’s two fold. Like you’re forcing them to finish their plate, which is a whole different conversation, which I, you know, I’m very passionate about too. But then you’re also saying, okay, finish the plate because you’re going to overstuff yourself and not listen to your hunger cues, because when you finish that, we’ll go get ice cream.
00;10;55;01 – 00;11;10;09
Dr. Mona
And I mean, oh my gosh, like, of course, I don’t know a lot of people who don’t love ice cream as long as they’re not got like this intolerance. And so, yeah, I’d be like, okay, let me starve down this food that I’m not even if I like it, I’m not hungry. And I’m like, so not. And so now not only am I not listening to my cues.
00;11;10;16 – 00;11;26;29
Dr. Mona
I’m looking at the sweet treat as a reward. So we’re doing that. You know, you talked about making a big deal. You talked about okay. Yeah. If you eat this you can have this. And so then it becomes this whole psychological thing. And like, the other thing, you know, I was talking to my husband about is the emotional connection we create with sweets.
00;11;26;29 – 00;11;44;15
Dr. Mona
Like in our culture, like when you’re sad or upset, it’s like, okay, eat this cookie. Like, eat this thing. And not to say that we can’t have cookies when we’re sad. I’m not saying that we can’t eat stuff because it’s happy, right? But there is this sort of like, reasoning that happened when we were growing up of like, hey, oh, you’re so sad.
00;11;44;15 – 00;12;02;23
Dr. Mona
Okay, have this cookie or have this thing, and there’s a very specific Indian cookie that is called parle-g that was very common. It’s called a glucose biscuit because it has so much sugar. And it’s like your comfort food and right again, comfort. I’m not against comfort foods. I think it’s wonderful. But then, yeah, we’re creating this association, like you said at the beginning that.
00;12;02;23 – 00;12;19;07
Dr. Mona
Yeah. Oh I need I need this to feel better about my day. I deserve this, I deserve because I did X, Y, and Z throughout my day. I deserve to sit down and have a whole thing of cookies, a whole tray of Girl Scout cookies when we’re not learning moderation. And that’s scary, right?
00;12;19;07 – 00;12;36;13
Jennifer Anderson
Yeah, yeah, I failed my first driver’s test when I was 16, and I was devastated. And my mom was like, oh, let’s go out for ice cream. And she go, I don’t know, there’s an ice cream shop that I don’t know. It was like in my memory, it was probably eight inches of like ice cream and oh, wow.
00;12;36;14 – 00;13;00;13
Jennifer Anderson
And it was like the expectation at that time with whoever was that it was like, because you’re sad, you’re going to eat the whole ice cream cone. And I did, and I just remember feeling so sick thinking like, damn, I really feeling better. And I think back on that, I, like you said, the ability of food to help us feel better can be a gift at times.
00;13;00;15 – 00;13;24;07
Jennifer Anderson
At the same time, personally I find that not being able to address my emotions and not being able to address the fact that I failed my driver’s test and that really ice cream, that was the solution for that. Guess what? Ice cream did not solve my problem. Failing my driver’s test, it would have been. And my mom has been great about this.
00;13;24;07 – 00;13;43;27
Jennifer Anderson
This is just one situation, but I think it would have been just as helpful for her to be like, wow, I’m so sorry that you feel that that you must be so upset. And I think in terms of me and my emotional development, that would have been a much more helpful skill because I’ve had to learn a lot of those skills later as an adult.
00;13;44;01 – 00;14;05;27
Jennifer Anderson
Yeah, and I couldn’t really. You have used those skills in my 20s when I didn’t have them, because ice cream and cookies were my solution. So I’m like an all like, give me all the solutions, give me the cookies, but also give me the ability to talk to the ability to talk about my emotions.
00;14;05;29 – 00;14;27;09
Dr. Mona
And that’s your follow up. Just a small dose of the real relatable and eye opening conversations we love to have here. If you smiled, nodded, or had an moment, go ahead and download, follow and share this episode with a friend. Let’s grow this village together for more everyday parenting wins and real talk. Hang out with us on Instagram at the PedsDocTalk podcast.
00;14;27;16 – 00;14;42;28
Dr. Mona
Want more? Dive into the full episode and more at PedsDocTalk.com. Because parenting is better with support and remember consistency is key. Humor is medicine and follow ups are everything. I’m Doctor Mona. See you next time for your next dose.
Please note that our transcript may not exactly match the final audio, as minor edits or adjustments could be made during production.
Need help? We’ve got you covered.
All information presented on this blog, my Instagram, and my podcast is for educational purposes and should not be taken as personal medical advice. These platforms are to educate and should not replace the medical judgment of a licensed healthcare provider who is evaluating a patient.
It is the responsibility of the guardian to seek appropriate medical attention when they are concerned about their child.
All opinions are my own and do not reflect the opinions of my employer or hospitals I may be affiliated with.